The Rooster Guide to Buying a Used Car: Spotting the Red Flags

2/6/2026

Buying a second-hand car in the UK can be one of the best ways to get great value on wheels — but it also comes with risks. From dodgy sellers to hidden faults, there’s a lot that can go wrong if you don’t know what to look out for. Being thorough pays off: performing the right checks and understanding warning signs helps you avoid buying a used car that leaves you with costly surprises down the road.

Early Warning Signs Before You Even View the Car

Seller and Sales Process Signals

Before you even step foot near the vehicle, certain behaviours can indicate trouble:

Unrealistically Low Price: If a deal looks too good to be true, it very often is — low pricing can hide stolen vehicles, hidden finance, major damage, or outright scams.
Pressure Tactics: Sellers who push you to decide quickly, pay a deposit straight away, or skip checks are not acting in your best interest.
Odd Viewing Locations: A private seller should be happy to show the car at their home address — the one on the V5C. Meeting in random car parks or lay-bys could signal issues with ownership or location.
No Inspection or Test Drive Allowed: If they don’t want you to bring an independent mechanic or take the car on a decent run, that’s a huge red flag.
Request for Untraceable Payment: Never deal in cash without a receipt or payment methods that can’t be traced — it’s a common tactic in used-car scams.

Documentation and History Checklist

The car’s paperwork reveals its story — and any gaps can indicate a problem. When buying a used car it is important to check the key documents:

Key Documents to Check

Complete V5C Logbook: Make sure the V5C is original (not a photocopy), and that the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) on the document matches the VIN stamped on the car.
MOT History: Use the UK government’s free MOT history service to check past tests, advisories and mileage records — repeated failures or large gaps in testing can point to neglect.
Service History: A comprehensive record of services, especially major jobs (timing belt, clutch, brake servicing), shows the car has been cared for. Gaps here are worth questioning.
Mileage Consistency: Clocking (rolling back the odometer) is an unfortunately common fraud. Check that mileage aligns with MOT and servicing records, and that wear on seats, pedals and steering matches the mileage.
Outstanding Finance / Theft / Write-Off Checks: Always run a full vehicle history check to make sure there’s no hidden finance registered against the car or a history of theft or write-off status.

Exterior & Cosmetic Inspection

Examine the car’s outward condition — many hidden problems show up here first.

What to Look For

Bodywork Issues: Rust patches, mismatched paint, dents, or panels that don’t line up can indicate accident repairs or deeper corrosion issues.
Glass and Lights: Check windscreens and windows for chips; all lights must work and lenses should not be cracked.
Tyres: Legal tread depth in the UK is 1.6 mm, but 3 mm or more is safer. Watch for uneven wear — it can be a sign of alignment or suspension problems.
Undercarriage Rust: Especially on older UK cars, corrosion can take hold beneath the surface — check wheel arches, sills and door bottoms carefully.

Interior and Electronics

Once inside, check both comfort and functionality.

Interior Red Flags

Excessive Wear: If tyres, seats, carpets or steering wheel are worn more than expected for the mileage shown, it could be masking clocked mileage.
Dashboard Lights: All lights should flash on start-up and then go off — any that stay illuminated need investigating.
Electronics Check: All windows, mirrors, infotainment systems, heating and electrical accessories should function correctly.
Smells & Moisture: Musty or damp smells can indicate water ingress — often a sign of leaks that may be expensive to fix.

Mechanical & Test Drive Checks

The test drive is where many hidden issues show themselves.

Things to Listen & Feel For

Strange Engine Noises: Knocking, ticking or rattling sounds likely mean mechanical issues.
Smoke from the Tailpipe: Blue smoke can point to oil burning; black smoke suggests fuel system issues.
Steering & Brakes: The car should track straight and brakes should feel firm — pulling to one side or spongy brakes are both red flags.
Fluid Leaks: Before and after driving, check the ground for oil or coolant spots.
Gearbox Function: Gears should change smoothly whether manual or automatic — crunching or hesitation can mean expensive transmission problems.

Questions to Ask the Seller

Getting the right answers can save you headaches later:

Why are you selling the car?
How long have you owned it?
Do you have full service and MOT records?
Has the car ever had major repairs or accidents?
Is there any outstanding finance?
Can I take it for an independent inspection?

Final Steps Before You Buy

Negotiate Based on Findings: Use any small issues you find to negotiate a fair price.
Secure Payment & Receipt: Use a traceable payment method and get a signed receipt with all car details.
Tax & Insurance: In the UK, you must tax and insure the vehicle before driving away.

By checking all of the above before you commit to buying a used car, you’ll be far less likely to walk away with a car that becomes an expensive burden — and you’ll make your used car purchase with confidence.

Download Rooster today to save on all things car. Check out car maintenance advice here.