New vs. Used Car: A 2025 Financial Breakdown
For decades, the “golden rule” of motoring finance was simple: avoid the showroom floor to avoid the initial hit to your wallet. However, the chaotic post-pandemic market turned this logic on its head, with second-hand prices occasionally rivalling brand-new models. As we settle into this year, the market is finally correcting itself. Supply chains have normalised and inventory is back, but high interest rates have introduced a new challenge. If you are standing on the dealership forecourt today, simply looking at the sticker price isn’t enough. To make the smartest decision regarding a new vs used car 2025, you need to look strictly at the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO).
The Depreciation Truth: Is It Still the “Silent Killer”?
Depreciation remains the single largest cost of owning a brand-new vehicle, but the curve looks different in 2025 than it did five years ago.
Historically, a new car would lose 20% of its value in the first year and roughly 60% after three years. In 2025, while depreciation has returned to “normal” levels compared to the inflated prices of recent years, high demand for fuel-efficient hybrids and affordable SUVs has kept used values surprisingly resilient.
The Bottom Line: If you plan to keep your car for 10+ years, depreciation is largely irrelevant. However, if you like to upgrade every 3–4 years via PCP (Personal Contract Purchase), buying new is still the more expensive route initially—unless you factor in the “financing gap.”
The Hidden Financial Factor: Interest Rates & Finance
This is where the traditional advice often fails in the current economic climate. Interest rates remain elevated, but there is a massive disparity between new and used financing.
The Advantage of Buying New
Manufacturers are incentivised to move stock. To combat high market rates, many automakers are offering subsidised financing on new 2025 models—sometimes as low as 0% or 2.9% APR for well-qualified buyers. This can save you thousands of pounds in interest over the life of a PCP or HP (Hire Purchase) deal, potentially offsetting the higher list price of the vehicle.
The Reality of Used Car Loans
Used car finance generally carries significantly higher interest rates—often double or triple what you might find for a new car. A “cheaper” used car with a 10.9% APR might end up costing you nearly the same monthly payment as a new car with a promotional 1.9% rate.
Maintenance, Warranty, and the MOT
When calculating the financial breakdown for a new vs used car 2025, you cannot ignore the “peace of mind” tax.
- The Warranty Shield: New cars come with manufacturer warranties (usually 3 to 7 years depending on the brand) and no need for an MOT for the first three years. With labour costs at garages rising across the UK, this coverage is a significant financial asset.
- The Used Car Gamble: A vehicle that is 5 years old may be cheaper to buy, but it is entering the window where “wear and tear” items fail. You must budget for tyres, brake pads, and potentially larger repairs like timing belts or clutch work, alongside the annual MOT test fee and any required remedial work.
The 2025 Verdict
So, which is the financial winner?
- Buy Used If: You can pay cash or secure a low personal loan rate, and you are happy to handle minor maintenance. The sweet spot in 2025 is a 4-year-old vehicle that has already taken the steepest depreciation hit.
- Buy New If: You rely on monthly finance. The subsidised interest rates and full warranty coverage on 2025 models often make the monthly cost of ownership competitive with late-model used cars, with zero risk of surprise repair bills.
Before signing on the dotted line, run the numbers not just on the price tag, but on the finance interest, insurance groups, and expected maintenance over the next five years.
How Rooster Can Help
Rooster also allows you to list your current car for sale and browse for your next reliable motor, ensuring the transition to your next vehicle is as smooth as possible. So whether you’re looking for new vs used car 2025, Rooster has you covered.
Download Rooster today to start saving and browsing.
